He was never seen in either the Dark Forest or StarClan.
Didn't a Erin say he was in Starclan?
I think he did. If attempting to kill a cat gets you sent to the Dark Forest (Like what happened to Hawkfrost). But attempting to kill four cats, oh, it's good. So Ashfur is in StarClan. Makes complete sense *sarcasm* (This is Gingerheart. My siggie isn't working)
YAY! *Happy dance* Clever doesn't like Ashfur! ~Ginger