Oooooh that is a hard one! Well, Tigerstar did LOTS of horrible stuff, and he is the one who brought Scourge into the forest, sooo I'm going with Tigerstar. -Leopardfire01
Even when Tigerstar did all that stuff I think I'll have to go with Scourge.. I think he was truly evil. He learned how to live for blood and started to become evil at a very young age. He started putting dog teeth in his collar as a kit! Growing up he never had a warrior code to guide him in even the slightest way he grew up being pushed around and bullied by his sibilings Socks and Ruby while Tigerstar grew up with cats who loved him following the warrior code. Scourge's group of Bloodclan cats were worse than Tigerstar's group of Rouges. Bloodclan cats were taught to kill with even the slightest mistake and were forced to savenge for food and fight for their lives. When Tigerstar died cats kept fighting, but when Scourge died it showed how much power he had, ALL his cats stopped fighting cause they felt with their leader dead there was nothing to fight for.. So I think Scourge's empire was more deadly. Hawkbreath]] *Swoop Swoop* 22:13, August 6, 2013 (UTC)
I agree with Hawk.